We’re Not Just Another Insurance Company

McKillop Mutual Insurance is not just another insurance company.  Not just because we have been meeting the insurance needs of our customers since 1876, and not just because we’re a mutual insurance company, and as such our policyholders have a voice in electing our Board of Directors and sharing in the company’s profits.  We’re different because, at McKillop, we keep it simple.

Our staff, agents and brokers, who work, live and raise their families in the same communities you do, will provide you with the coverages you need at a fair and competitive price, without making it overly complicated.  For us, it’s not about upsell or cross sell, or selling at all.  It’s about getting to know the needs that are unique to you and providing an insurance solution to protect them. And if you suffer a loss, we will work together to get you back on your feet as quickly as possible. That is our promise……plain and simple!

To discuss your unique insurance needs please contact one of our agents or brokers, they’ll be glad to help you.

COVID-19 Measures

At McKillop Mutual Insurance, we are taking essential precautionary measures as the COVID-19 situation continues to unfold.  The wellbeing of our staff, agents, brokers, policyholders and community is our top priority.

Precautions include;

• Our office in Seaforth remains open, but with restricted access.
• Please do not enter if you have recently traveled, or if you are experiencing symptoms.
• Consider using the telephone or technology for your transactions.
• You can contact your agent or broker by phone or email.
• Payments can be made over the phone or on line.

We apologize for the inconvenience, but want to thank you for your patience!

Meet Our Agents

Meet Our Brokers

Gaiser Elliott Insurance Brokers
Mcdonagh Insurance Brokers Ltd.
Huronview Insurance Brokers Ltd.
MacEwan & Feagan Insurance Brokers Ltd.